Although this might not be the most beautiful pattern in this book, it immediately caught my eye. I love the simple pattern, and the easy and casual feel of the top in the photos in the book. But my finished version of this top leaves me rather disappointed. I love the neck and top part of the shirt, but from the armpits down, I think it's kind of a mess. I have almost made up my mind to frog it and make something else instead.
I had made some modifications. I chose to knit my top in Knitpick's Comfy, in a beautiful shade of rosy pink called Poesy. Love it! I wanted to make the top out of a yarn that would be good for warmer weather wear, and chose not to knit it in wool. (This may have been part of my problem.)
After knitting down to the armpits and finding the top to be uncomfortably snug, I tore my knitting out and started again. The top starts with the circular yoke, and I started the pattern after the first increase, making the top a bit bigger from the beginning. To avoid have the neck opening be too large, I cast on with a #4 needle for a few rows, then switched to a #6 needle. I knit with the #6 almost to the shoulders before switching to a #7 needle to complete the rest of the garment.
I think there's another problem with the pattern in knitting the yoke. The pattern says to do 5 repeats for the smaller sizes and only 4 repeats for the larger sizes. That doesn't make sense. I did 5 repeats for mine. Four repeats would not have been big enough or wide enough to reach my shoulders, which are somewhat narrow.
I added a little shaping through the body and chose to add ribbing to the bottom edge. The original top has a rolled edge on the bottom. But in my experience, rolled edges always roll up to my belly button every time I sit down and I spend way too much time pulling down my shirt. Ugh. I didn't want my ribbing to be too distracting from the pattern of the top, so I chose a 4 knit, 2 purl rib. I think it maintains the eyelet pattern of the top and yet still keeps the edge from rolling up. It's one thing that seemed to work right.
Ultimately, my finished top doesn't really look like the one in the book, nor do I think it's very pretty. Maybe if I hadn't increased the size, the shirt would have fit snugger and the eyelets would have opened more and created a ripple? Maybe, but I think it would have been uncomfortably tight for me and I wouldn't have enjoyed wearing the shirt. Or, maybe if I had used wool instead of cotton, the lace would have opened up more during the blocking process? Who knows, but I think I will be frogging this top and making the Gemini top, which has a similar look and shape, from this month's Knitty instead.
Stay tuned for more misadventures in knitting :)